Okay, so I'm likely going to delete this once the name has been determined because it feels way too specific and identifying, but I wanted to put all the Head Stuff about naming the kid here because the brain isn't braining. The factors are:
1) AFAB
2) single-syllable last name starting with a Y
3) two middle names which I've already figured out because her sister has two and god forbid she feel left out, y'know? Okay.
Amethyst
Pros: I've never met one and so have no negative connotations; it's the name of a character in Steven Universe that I dig
Cons: it seems like a roundabout way of naming someone Crystal; do I love gemstones that much? Not really, but gems and jewelry-making are in the family zeitgeist, so...maybe?
Virginia
Pros: family name; it seems a little less likely these days that the virgin teasing will ensue; three syllables, and goes pretty well with my extant child's name; Ginny is a cute nickname and I never meet little Jenny's anymore so - potentially unique
Cons: the state thing; there's a y sound within the last syllable which makes it medium-high on the awkward-with-surname scale (AWSS); like, it does mean virgin which is...not the greatest
Vesper
Pros: it's pretty; I've never met one; means evening star or evening prayer which is...fine
Cons: I'm pretty sure there's a Bond Girl named Vesper something; <3 syllables; S and L both say it "sounds like a boy name" although that factoid could just as well belong under pros
Eliza
Pros: easy; 3 syllables; there's already kind of a running gag where one set of grandparents call the kid "Betty" and that would make more sense with this name without going full Elizabeth; uh...Eliza Schuyler from Hamilton, I guess?
Cons: I know a few people with this name and while I don't have negative connotations per se it's also pretty close to Liz, Elizabeth, and Elsbeth none of which I feel like I can fuck with, honestly; it means "pledged to God" (kind of a big commitment to lay on an infant - no thanks)
Coraline (the front-runner as of 1/17/26)
Pros: 3 syllables; have never met anyone named Coraline (yet! I'm pretty sure it's on the upswing, though) the movie is a staple at my house with all the kids; L and S both have fairly to very positive opinions of the name; Cora and Coral are both potential nicknames that are pretty alright; it means "coral" which is pretty innocuous, really
Cons: Neil Gaiman is a terrible person and while I consider the movie to be separate from the book and, ergo, the author I'm sure most people don't; the issue with it getting confused for Caroline - although, probably not in Alaska judging by the sheer amount of Coraline costumes I saw at the Fall Festival this year; all the subtext (and overt text!) with the plot of the movie itself...although she's a pretty badass heroine as far as those things go 🤷
Illuminata/Illuminada/Lumina
Pros: >3 syllables; the built-in nickname is cute as hell (Lumi!); have never met anyone named any of those variations; they all have meanings similar to "filled with light" which is nice - but perhaps a lot to lay on a kid; very Catholic, so it fits in with the in-laws (although they seem pretty nonplussed by it)
Cons: the immediate connotation with the first two variations is illuminati. So...yup; nobody else really seems to like it, just me - although should it matter all that much? Everyone's lucky I'm not naming her Chappell Damn Roan; one of two names on this list that are derived from one of my favorite video games
Athena
Pros: 3 syllables; literally a Classic; if you're going to name your kid after a goddess she's probably the one to go with
Cons: It's just not a "fuck yes!", you know? And I have some strong head-canon around it being kind of a rich white-hippie name; wow, Clara, judgmental much?
Augustina
Pros: >3 syllables; a family name (ish...from the way-back); means "majestic", which kind of goes with my existing kid's name...uh...sort of; have only ever met one kid named Augustina and she was a baby at the time, so I don't have many negative associations
Cons: Maybe it's because it starts with an A, but I just...don't know? Maybe she'll pop out and look like an Augustina and that'll be that; nobody has reacted to it whatsoever - positively or negatively
Louisa
Pros: 3 syllables; this probably belongs under both pros and cons, but it means "renowned warrior"; has a bit of a latin feel and reminds me of Luisa from Encanto
Cons: We had a goat named Louise, which is pretty close; it's also giving middle-aged British lady digging in her garden in Devon or some such who ends up being the murderer in a Miss Marple
Rowena
Pros: 3 syllables; have never met one; pretty positive meaning - unfortunately nothing to do with rowan trees, however
Cons: I would want it pronounced row-ENN-ah and don't know how intuitive that would be - for me even; apparently there are Harry Potter associations which I don't love
Merida
Pros: L suggested this one at one point and I kind of like it; the Brave thing, obviously; doesn't seem to have a relationship to the "bitter" meaning that seems to haunt most variations on Mary; is, apparently, a city in Mexico so somewhat culturally appropriate
Cons: I'm not super-compelled by it; although a badass heroine, still a Disney name and that's going to give people the wrong impression (i.e., that I wish upon a star like that, which I don't)
Rosamund
Pros: kind of Shakespearean but not as oversaturated as, say, Juliet; I like Rosamund Pike alright - she's Moiraine in Wheel of Time as well as the Gone Girl in Gone Girl; a great-grandparent is named Rose so that's pretty close; L could call her "Rosie" which she's recently said she wants to do
Cons: I'm not sure how to pronounce it and neither will most other people, probably; invites the nickname "Roz" which makes me think of Frasier but probably her peers will think of The Wild Robot which isn't altogether a bad thing I suppose
Hela (Helena?Helene?)
Pros: have only met one Helena and she was pretty groovy and went by Peaches; S has been adamant that the only name he likes is Hela which is a preference at least I guess; I super-enjoyed the one professor I had named Helene
Cons: Hela is a Marvel character and also the actual deadass goddess of death in Norse mythology none of which is bad per se but certainly something to think about; Hela does not go with the last name it's awkward as hell (see what I did there?); the only pronunciation of Helene that truly like is the French one and it's going to be pretty damn hard to enforce that; Helena, Montana
Satia
Pros: have never met & etc
Cons: another video game name; Turkish in origin (not bad, but nobody is at all Turkish at least according to 23andme); it's giving sativa - which is something to think about, especially in Alaska; nobody will know how to pronounce it; once they do, it's a bit awkward with the last name due to the "y" sound in the last phoneme; means "truthful, virtuous" which is kind of a lot to put on a kid
Sabine
Pros: have never met & etc
Cons: again with the pronunciation and the French (which I like, but is it user-friendly? Do I care? These are the questions.); Seven Brides for Seven Brothers has kind of ruined the whole concept of the Sabine women for me and even if not - does anyone really want a history lesson for a name? And even if they do, a history lesson about abduction and rape, though?; otherwise it's just the name of group of people from a very specific region of Italy that, yes, I probably am distantly related to, but...
Aravis
Pros: I think it's just a badass name; and an underrated Chronicles of Narnia character - way more likable than most of 'em
Cons: It's the name of a mountain range and has no further meaning attached; nobody will know how to pronounce it (again); I'm not a super-C.S. Lewis-y person at this point in my life and naming my child Aravis would probably suggest otherwise
Gisele
Pros: a family name, kinda
Cons: apparently the way I would want to pronounce it is incorrect (I like GUY-sell, but everyone else in the world uses a soft g); it means "hostage", I think?; S has said he doesn't know how to pronounce it and doesn't want to learn so there's that
Victoria
Pros: it's really easy - Victoria? Everyone knows her; potential for Tori as a nickname (this is a little 90s, however); it just means "victorious" which is pretty unobjectionable; Tori Amos
Cons: Queen Victoria; I have known at least two people with this name and, although I liked both of them, I just...don't know?; invites the nickname "Vicky" which gives me the ick; it was allegedly fairly popular in 2024
Peregrine
Pros: I feel like Peregrine as a girl's name would be pretty badass; I would call her Perry the Platypus - is that bullying? Maybe; other nicknames seem to include Pippa and Pippin; means pilgrim or traveler which I don't personally think is negative or burdensome, but...; if I'm going to name one kid after an animal I may as well name the second one after an animal too 🤣
Cons: evidently seen as uppity in Britain; I always forget LOTR's Pippin's long name is actually Peregrine, but that's not such a bad thing in Alaska but also, copy and paste my concerns about Aravis; the falcon, although this might be more neutral than negative
Talula
Pros: Goes with L's name a bit; the right number of syllables; there's a Tori Amos song by that name
Cons: A bit twee; fairly popular; there's some debate as to whether or not there is an Irish name it's derived from with most people saying "nawp" which means it's solely Native American which would be a hard no; L says that it sounds "silly"; it feels wrong to spell it without the extra l and h but that's what makes it more Irish less Native, allegedly
Pauline
Pros: a family name - kind of; Polly would be a cute nickname
Cons: I can't really imagine how that would play out for them as an adult; it's has kind of a "hard" feel to it; it really just means "little" or "the younger" which, while technically accurate, seems mean
Names not under consideration that I still kinda like:
Trula (doesn't work with the last name whatsoever)
Gemma (girl, same)
Sophia (got way too popular in the past 15 years; I guess we just all love Howl's Moving Castle that much - who can blame us)
...and there you have it!